The scope of administrative justice is limited to those acts of administrative authorities which directly affect the rights or obligations of an individual
Legal principle stated by the Court:
A statement by the originator of classified information regarding the refusal to grant consent to its disclosure constitutes a procedural act without direct legal effects on a party to the proceedings and is therefore not subject to separate judicial review.
A measure under Section 3(1)(c) of the Administrative Court Code is only an administrative act capable of directly affecting the rights, legally protected interests or obligations of its addressee. An administrative act without immediate legal effects on the legal position of the addressee is not subject to separate review by an administrative court.
On 16th July 2026, The Supreme Administrative Court of the Slovak Republic, by judgment Case. No. 2Sak2/2026, dismissed the plaintiff’s cassation appeal against the judgment of the Administrative Court in Bratislava.
In the case in question, the plaintiff (a national of the Arab Republic of Egypt) was administratively deported from the Slovak Republic on the basis of information contained in a classified document. In the case in question, the claimant (a national of the Arab Republic of Egypt) was administratively deported from the Slovak Republic on the basis of information contained in a classified document. Although he lodged an administrative action against the decision on administrative deportation, he did so after the statutory time limit had expired, and the action was therefore dismissed.
The plaintiff subsequently brought an administrative action seeking a review of the measure by which the legal predecessor of Defendant 2 (the National Counter-Terrorism Unit of the National Criminal Agency of the Presidium of the Police Force ) notified Defendant 1 (the Foreigners’ Police Department of the Police Force Bratislava) that it would not grant the plaintiff’s legal representative authorisation for a one-off disclosure of classified information. At the same time, the plaintiff requested that Defendants 1 and 2 be ordered to disclose the classified information which formed the basis of the decision on his deportation.
The Administrative Court in Bratislava dismissed the action in so far as it challenged the measure and rejected the part seeking to impose an obligation on defendants 1 and 2 to disclose the requested classified information. The court also emphasised that the plaintiff cannot, through proceedings for access to classified information, seek to remedy the missed deadline for reviewing a final decision on administrative deportation. Proceedings for access to the case file cannot serve as a substitute for the proper and timely bringing of an administrative action against the decision on the merits of the case.
The Court of Cassation upheld the administrative court’s conclusion that the refusal by the originator of the classified information is merely a preliminary procedural act which, in itself, does not directly infringe the applicant’s rights. It was solely an expression of the originator’s position in accordance with the Act on the Protection of Classified Information. This act alone did not determine the plaintiff’s rights or obligations. The first defendant, who was the sole authority authorised to deal with the request in question, decided on the plaintiff’s request for access to the administrative file. The contested measure therefore, in and of itself, did not deprive the plaintiff of any right, nor did it restrict the scope of his rights or alter the manner of their exercise. Its significance lay solely in the fact that it constituted the basis, as required by law, for a decision by another administrative authority. Such a procedural act is therefore not capable of directly infringing the plaintiff’s subjective rights and cannot be regarded as a measure within the meaning of Section 3(1)(c) of the Administrative Court Code, including in the light of the conclusions set out in the judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of the Slovak Republic, Case. No. 8Svk/3/2024, which was based on the opinion of the Grand Panel expressed in its decision, Case No. 19Svs/2/2022.
The Court of Cassation further held that access to administrative files and the disclosure of information under the Freedom of Information Act constitute two separate legal regimes with different rules. If a party to the proceedings requests access to the administrative file, the administrative authority is not entitled to treat that request as an application under the Freedom of Information Act.
The judgment of the Court of Cassation confirms that the subject-matter of administrative justice is limited to those acts of administrative authorities which directly affect the rights or obligations of an individual. Underlying opinions and procedural acts in themselves, which have no legal effect of their own, are not subject to separate judicial review.
The decision was adopted by Panel No. 2 of the Supreme Administrative Court, composed of: the President of the Panel, JUDr. Elena Berthotyová, PhD. (judge-rapporteur); and the judges: JUDr. Pavol Naď and Prof. JUDr. Juraj Vačok, PhD.
You can find the decision in Case No. 2Sak2/2026 in the ‘Decisions’ section on the website of The Supreme Administrative Court of the Slovak Republic.